Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Cleantech Resource Extraction

Resource extraction and harvesting technologies are one of the patentECO Indexes, and they can include cleantech. These technologies provide the raw materials needed to support societies and they provide a fundamental basis for the economic engine fueled by a free market economy.

In this post, two recent cleantech patents in different areas of resource extraction – hydraulic fracturing or “fracing” and commercial fish trawling – are discussed.

The patent cognoscenti often use the word “teach”, to explain what an inventor's invention is.  Our definition of "teach" is:
“An inventor is granted an exclusive right to their invention in exchange for teaching others skilled in the art how to make their invention by way of the information in the patent. With respect to prior art, teach is defined as informing and instructing by way of the documents making up the prior art. The prior art references teach the technology disclosed in them or revealed by them.”  (For more patent-speak, see the Way Better Patents Glossary.)
The first patent below provides excellent teaching regarding the fracing process.

Improving Hydraulic Fracturing Efficiency

Hydraulic fracturing (“fracing” or “fracking”) is a technique used to stimulate the production of gases and fluids from underground geologic formations. It is based on the high pressure injection of fluids into a gas or oil wellbore for the purpose of fracturing the geologic formation to increase its permeability, thus stimulating the flow of the desired products into the wellbore. Included in the injected fluid is a “proppant”, typically sand, that holds the fracture open and permeable after the fluid has dispersed. The increased formation permeability, and therefore product flow, will be a function of the total length of the propped fractures. Previous Inkling posts on fracing are here and here.

Patent US 8,127,850, “Method of treating subterranean formations using sequential proppant stages” seeks to increase the effective propped lengths by using ultra lightweight (ULW) proppants. The patent was issued to Harold Dean Brannon (Magnolia, TX) and six co-inventors on March 6, 2012, and was assigned to Baker Hughes Incorporated (Houston, TX).

In Brannon et al.’s invention the ULW proppants are provided in two stages, the first being either more dense or of a different particle size than the second-stage proppant. The two-stage pumping of proppants into the formation fractures increases the effective propped length of the fractures, and thus increases the overall permeability (and yield) of the formation over a one-stage proppant fracing operation.
Brannon et al. teach the hydraulic fracturing process:
During hydraulic fracturing, a viscosified fracturing fluid is pumped at high pressures and at high rates into a wellbore to initiate and propagate a hydraulic fracture. Once the natural reservoir pressures are exceeded, the fluid induces a fracture in the formation and transports the proppant into the fracture. The fluid used to initiate and propagate the fracture is commonly known as the “pad”. The pad may contain a heavy density fine particulate, such as fine mesh sand, for fluid loss control, or larger grain sand to abrade perforations or near-wellbore tortuosity. Once the fracture is initiated, subsequent stages of viscosified fracturing fluid containing chemical agents such as breakers, and containing proppants are pumped into the created fracture. The fracture generally continues to grow during pumping and the proppant remains in the fracture in the form of a permeable “pack” that serves to “prop” the fracture open. Once the treatment is completed, the fracture closes onto the proppants which maintain the fracture open, providing a highly conductive pathway for hydrocarbons and/or other formation fluids to flow into the wellbore. The fracturing fluid ultimately “leaks off” into the surrounding formation. The treatment design generally requires the fracturing fluid to reach maximum viscosity as it enters the fracture which affects the fracture length and width.
Fracturing fluids, including those containing breakers, typically exhibit poor transport properties. High pumping rates are required in order to impart a sufficient velocity for placement of the proppant in the fracture. In such treatments, the proppant tends to settle, forming a ‘proppant bank’, as the linear slurry velocity falls as a function of the distance from the wellbore. This effect is further believed to result in reduced stimulation efficiency as the effective propped length is relatively short. In addition, much of the settled proppant is often below the productive interval. 
The recovery of the fracturing fluid is accomplished by reducing the viscosity of the fluid to a low value such that it flows naturally from the formation under the influence of formation fluids and pressure. This viscosity reduction or conversion is referred to as “breaking”. Historically, the application of breaking fluids as fracturing fluids at elevated temperatures, i.e., above about 120–130 °F., has been a compromise between maintaining proppant transport and achieving the desired fracture conductivity, measured in terms of effective propped fracture length. Conventional oxidative breakers react rapidly at elevated temperatures, potentially leading to catastrophic loss of proppant transport. Encapsulated oxidative breakers have experienced limited utility at elevated temperatures due to a tendency to release prematurely or to have been rendered ineffective through payload self-degradation prior to release.
By increasing the permeability and yield of individual wells through the use of this newly-patented technology, more natural gas and oil will be available, more profits will be obtained by the producers, more jobs and employee benefits by those produces can be sustained, more money will flow into ancillary purchases in the surrounding communities, and the closer to energy independence the US will be (assuming, of course, that the increased production is not negated by onerous government regulations).

These are good outcomes from using different types of sand.

Release the Young Fishes!

We turn from resource extraction below ground to resource harvesting from the seas.
Ireland, not commonly thought of as a commercial fishing nation, nonetheless derives a significant fisheries harvest from its surrounding seas and oceans. These activities are described in the 2009 “Atlas of the Commercial Fisheries Around Ireland”, published by the Marine Institute. The top five most economically valuable fisheries species landed by Irish vessels in 2008 were: mackeral, Nephrops (aka Norway lobster or Dublin Bay prawn, a slim, orange-pink lobster), horse mackeral, monkfish, and edible crab, totalling €101 billion (approximately equivalent to $76.3 billion in 2012 dollars).
Irish inventor Danny Gallagher and three co-inventors have developed a new “Netting arrangement” for pelagic (i.e., water column) and bottom commercial trawling, memorialized in US 8,191,305. The patent was granted on June 5, 2012, and is currently considered by the USPTO to be a trawl fishing net. We’ll see in January 2013 how that consideration changes with the introduction of the upcoming Cooperative Patent Classification System (CPC), based on the European Classification Office’s (EPO) ECLA system.

The ‘305 patent’s first claim is:
A trawl netting arrangement including a main netting component and at least one grid portion formed from a plurality of loops, each loop having four sides, two sides of each loop being formed from longitudinally arranged substantially parallel rigid members and the other two sides being flexible, the flexible sides interconnecting the substantially rigid sides from one another such that each loop of the grid is collapsible, a collapse of the loop effecting a bringing together of the substantially rigid sides.
What makes this invention cleantech?

We’ll let the inventor tell it, in keeping with the “teaching” of technological innovations in patents as described earlier in this post.

Gallagher, et al.:
The invention relates to fishing and in particular to trawling. The invention more particularly relates to netting arrangements for use in trawling such as pelagic or bottom trawling and used for selective discrimination in the catch so as to provide for improved selectivity in the size of the captured species. In one embodiment this may be used to reduce the possibility of capture of juvenile species, while in another it may be used to selectively disregard larger fish. 
BACKGROUND 
Pelagic trawling is the use of a cone-shaped net behind a boat to catch large schools of fish. It differs from benthic trawling–sometimes referred to as bottom trawling–in that as opposed to towing trawl nets along the sea floor, pelagic trawling provides for a towing higher up in the water column. In both trawling techniques, a flow of water passes through the net as the net is towed behind the fishing vessel. 
A fishing trawl may be considered as having two main portions: the trawl-net portion which is the extended area of netting that serves to capture a large volume and which tapers inwardly towards a collecting bag or cod-end, where the captured fish are retained until the trawl is recovered on board the fishing vessel where they are then released and processed. The body of the trawl-net is funnel-like, wide at its mouth and narrowing towards the cod-end. It is long enough to assure adequate flow of water and prevent fish from escaping the net after subsequent capture. It is made of different grades of netting, the size of the mesh of the netting decreasing from the front of the net towards the cod-end. The cod end is where fish are finally caught. The size of mesh in the cod end is a determinant of the size of fish which the net catches.
[snip] 
Such grading of species is important in modern fish management where there are strict controls on the volumes of fish caught and also on the minimum size of the catch. The use of larger mesh sizes in the collecting bag (cod end) was among the first technical measures imposed by fisheries managers to prevent the capture of juveniles. Such arrangements require the fish to reach the side netting to achieve their escape.
[snip] 
While the above described arrangements provide for a certain degree in selection in the size of the captured fish, there is a further need to provide a netting arrangement that provides for discriminative capture of the fish size. It is believed that whilst all of the above described arrangements improve the prospect of escape by juvenile species, there is still a need for an improved netting arrangement.
By incorporating improved size selection into the trawl net, the inventors do their part to harvest a renewable resource (fish), yet help protect the juvenile fishes by allowing them to escape.

Greentech indeed.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Government Interest Statements September 20, 2012


Each week Way Better Patents publishes a list of the latest patents and patent applications that contain Government Interest Statements or include a Joint Research Agreement (JRA) statement.  The list includes the patent information, the assignees, the funding agency, and the actual statement which usually includes the contract numbers for federally funded research efforts.  The JRA statement usually identifies the parties working together on the intellectual property.  

Here is a summary of published patent applications that contain a government interest statement or a joint research agreement statements for September 20, 2012.

Breakdown By Agency

46  Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
41  Department of Defense (DOD)
28  Department of Energy (DOE)
18  National Science Foundation (NSF)
4  National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
2  Department of Agriculture (USDA)
1  Department of Justice (DOJ)
1  Department of State (DOS)

Subject Matter of Government Interest Patent Applications
19  (424)  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
18  (435)  Chemistry: molecular biology and microbiology
7  (514)  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
6  (257)  Active solid-state devices
4  (073)  Measuring and testing
4  (244)  Aeronautics and astronautics
4  (506)  Combinatorial chemistry technology: method, library, apparatus
3  (250)  Radiant energy
3  (428)  Stock material or miscellaneous articles
3  (429)  Chemistry: electrical current producing apparatus, product, and process
3  (607)  Surgery: light, thermal, and electrical application
2  (205)  Electrolysis: processes, compositions used therein, and methods of preparing the compositions
2  (252)  Compositions
2  (324)  Electricity: measuring and testing
2  (342)  Communications: directive radio wave systems and devices
2  (356)  Optics: measuring and testing
2  (359)  Optical: systems and elements
2  (382)  Image analysis
2  (438)  Semiconductor device manufacturing: process
2  (600)  Surgery
2  (702)  Data processing: measuring, calibrating, or testing
2  (800)  Multicellular living organisms and unmodified parts thereof and related processes

This Week's Patent Applications By Location
This week Government Interest patent grants were granted to 132 US inventors, two (2) from the Peoples Republic of China, and one (1) each from Israel, the Netherlands, and Portugal. Inventors are identified based on the residence identify of the first named inventor. The breakdown of the States of residence of the US Inventors is:
  • 33    California
  • 10    New York
  •   8    Florida
  •   8    Massachusetts
  •   8    Texas
  •   6    Washington
  •   4    Arizona
  •   4    Colorado
  •   4    Maryland
  •   4    Michigan
  •   4    New Mexico
  •   4    Ohio
  •   4    Tennessee
  •   3    Illinois
  •   3    Indiana
  •   3    Pennsylvania
  •   3    Virginia
  •   2    Kansas
  •   2    North Carolina
  •   2    New Jersey
  •   2    Oregon
  •   2    Wisconsin

Friday, September 21, 2012

Patent It Yourself - A Self-Help Book

We'd like to believe that you can get all of the information you need from the internet and from the vast array of information on the USPTO website.  Sadly, it doesn't work that way.  When you've worn yourself out clicking on links and reach the point where you want to smash your computer to bits, it's time for a real book.  Even as patent nerds ourself, we often find ourselves reaching for this trusty little tome to get a quick answer about the basic mechanics of creating a patent application - hence it's inclusion on the Way Better Patents Reading List.  Even if you are working with a patent agent or attorney, this book will help you speak their language.



Patent It Yourself: Your Step-by-Step Guide to Filing at the U.S. Patent Office by David Pressman — The handbook to turn to when you are tired of mousing around the USPTO web site or in need of relief from patent attorney speak on how to get a patent.



Thursday, September 20, 2012

Government Interest Statements for September 13, 2012


Each week Way Better Patents publishes a list of the latest patents and patent applications that contain Government Interest Statements or include a Joint Research Agreement (JRA) statement.  The list includes the patent information, the assignees, the funding agency, and the actual statement which usually includes the contract numbers for federally funded research efforts.  The JRA statement usually identifies the parties working together on the intellectual property.  

Here is a summary of published patent applications that contain a government interest statement or a joint research agreement statements for September 13, 2012. 


Agencies
51  Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
28  Department of Defense (DOD)
18  Department of Energy (DOE)
12  National Science Foundation (NSF)
6  Small Business Administration (SBA)
3  National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
3  National Security Agency (NSA)
1  Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA)
1  Department of Agriculture (USDA)



The published patents cover the following scientific and technical domains within the US Patent Classification System.  Each class has a link to the definition at USPTO.

Government Interest - U.S. Classification
21  (424)  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
16  (514)  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
10  (435)  Chemistry: molecular biology and microbiology
4  (257)  Active solid-state devices
4  (348)  Television
3  (073)  Measuring and testing
3  (239)  Fluid sprinkling, spraying, and diffusing
3  (250)  Radiant energy
3  (604)  Surgery
2  (204)  Chemistry: electrical and wave energy
2  (307)  Electrical transmission or interconnection systems
2  (428)  Stock material or miscellaneous articles
2  (429)  Chemistry: electrical current producing apparatus, product, and process
2  (506)  Combinatorial chemistry technology: method, library, apparatus
2  (700)  Data processing: generic control systems or specific applications
2  (717)  Data processing: software development, installation, and management

Following is the geographic breakdown of the first named inventors on the patents:

Country
111  United States of America
1  Canada
1  China PRC
1  United Kingdom


US State
18  California
9  Massachusetts
9  Texas
7  Maryland
5  Illinois
5  New York
4  Florida
4  Indiana
4  North Carolina
4  New Mexico
4  Tennessee
4  Virginia
3  Connecticut
3  Michigan
2  Arkansas
2  Arizona
2  Georgia
2  Minnesota
2  Mississippi
2  New Jersey
2  Washington
2  Wisconsin

Wednesday, September 19, 2012

Government Interest Statements - September 18, 2012


Each week Way Better Patents publishes a list of the latest patents and patent applications that contain Government Interest Statements or include a Joint Research Agreement (JRA) statement.  The list includes the patent information, the assignees, the funding agency, and the actual statement which usually includes the contract numbers for federally funded research efforts.  The JRA statement usually identifies the parties working together on the intellectual property.  

Here is a summary of granted patents that contain a government interest statement or a joint research agreement statements for September 18th, 2012.  

Patents with Government Interest Statements — September 18, 2012


Weekly Summary — Federal Entity
Government Interest - U.S. Federal
42  Department of Defense (DOD)
41  Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
26  Department of Energy (DOE)
13  National Science Foundation (NSF)
3  Department of Commerce (DOC)
2  National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
2  Small Business Administration (SBA)
1  Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA)
1  Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
1  National Security Agency (NSA)
1  Department of Agriculture (USDA)


Subject Matter of Government Interest Patents
13  435  Chemistry: molecular biology and microbiology
12  514  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
8  424  Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions
7  250  Radiant energy
5  257  Active solid-state devices
4  436  Chemistry: analytical and immunological testing
3  089  Ordnance
3  324  Electricity: measuring and testing
3  356  Optics: measuring and testing
3  385  Optical waveguides
3  427  Coating processes
3  540  Organic compounds
3  700  Data processing: generic control systems or specific applications
3  702  Data processing: measuring, calibrating, or testing
2  052  Static structures
2  073  Measuring and testing
2  264  Plastic and nonmetallic article shaping or treating: processes
2  370  Multiplex communications
2  375  Pulse or digital communications
2  423  Chemistry of inorganic compounds
2  600  Surgery
2  607  Surgery: light, thermal, and electrical application
2  706  Data processing: artificial intelligence
2  707  Data processing: database and file management or data structures


This Week's Patents

This week Government Interest patent grants were granted to 132 US inventors, two (2) from the United Kingdom, and one (1) from Switzerland. Inventors are identified based on the residence identify of the first named inventor. The breakdown of the States of residence of the US Inventors is:
  • 31    California
  • 10    Florida
  •   9    New York
  •   9    Wisconsin
  •   8    Maryland
  •   7    Massachusetts
  •   5    Washington
  •   4    New Mexico
  •   4    Texas
  •   3    Colorado
  •   3    Michigan
  •   3    North Carolina
  •   3    Pennsylvania
  •   2    Arizona
  •   2    Connecticut
  •   2    Idaho
  •   2    Illinois
  •   2    Indiana
  •   2    Kansas
  •   2    Kentucky
  •   2    Mississippi
  •   2    Nebraska
  •   2    New Jersey
  •   2    Ohio

Get the Screen Shots

Drew Curtis, the CEO of Fark.com had the unpleasant experience of being sued for patent infringement by Gooseberry Natural Resources - a patent troll with no employees and an office in a strip mall in LA.

Mr. Curtis abandoned the standard "settle for a little as possible as quickly as possible" strategy of resolving patent infringement law suits and instead invoked the "show me where I'm infringing" strategy.  Get the proof of infringement.  Fight infringement rather than fighting the patent.  By not wasting time and money trying to have the patent invalidated, he focused instead on making the NPE prove infringement.

His TED Talk is a refreshing look at someone who chose to remove the cover of darkness from a patent infringement suit and settlement.  Regardless of your feelings toward patent assertion entities, everyone in the patentsphere benefits from moving the discussion of what is infringe and what isn't into the sunlight and away from platitudes like "the patent system if broken."



Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Strange USPTO Behavior

Jamie Love of Knowledge Ecology International just posted that the USPTO blocks access to "political/activist groups" including the ACLU, Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), and a host of other organizations.  According to Mr. Love the dailykos.com and rushlimbaugh.com are blocked but alijazeera.org and the huffingtonpost.com are not.  His post provides a short list of some of the organizations blocked and not blocked.

I've seen Mr. Love speak about Intellectual Property issues several times.  He provides thoughtful discussion on important intellectual property issues even if you don't always agree with what he says. It's hard to fathom a reason why his organization would be blocked.

Here is a link to Mr. Love's post.

The basic question on USPTO blocking these organizations is why?  Why should anyone be blocked?  Who made this decision?  Was it a political decision?  Was some risk posed by allowing people in these organizations to have access to USPTO's site?

A tweet from Mr. Love reports that he got a call from USPTO saying the filter that blocked the "political/activist organizations" has been removed.  While this is the right thing to do, the question remains, why did they block the sites in the first place?