Monday, September 10, 2012

Dark Wake and Data Centers - Green Tech HIghlights


Green technology energy efficiency inventions relating to saving power in the digital world are increasingly important in light of the latest information on data center electricity use:
  • Electricity used by data centers worldwide increased by about 56% from 2005 to 2010 instead of doubling (as it did from 2000 to 2005), while in the US it increased by about 36% instead of doubling.

  • Electricity used in global data centers in 2010 likely accounted for between 1.1% and 1.5% of total electricity use, respectively. For the US that number was between 1.7 and 2.2%.

  • Electricity used in US data centers in 2010 was significantly lower than predicted by the EPA’s 2007 report to Congress on data centers. That result reflected this study’s reduced electricity growth rates compared to earlier estimates, which were driven mainly by a lower server installed base than was earlier predicted rather than the efficiency improvements anticipated in the report to Congress.
(Source:  Jonathan Koomey. 2011. Growth in Data center electricity use 2005 to 2010. Oakland, CA: Analytics Press. August 1.  http://www.analyticspress.com/datacenters.html)


Both the U.S. Department of Energy and Gartner research revealed that the cost to power a typical server over its useful life can now exceed the original capital expenditure. Gartner notes that it can cost over $50,000 annually to power a single rack of servers.  The challenge being how to optimize servers so that you have the capacity for peak demand while avoiding using excessive energy during low demand periods.

Virtualization changes the energy use game but just a little.  Virtualizing as many servers as possible can increase overall utilization from around 10 percent (typical of dedicated servers) to between 20 percent and 30 percent, according to Clemens Pfeiffer, CTO of Power Assure.

Enter the dark wake.

Using dark wake technology the CPU and the network connections remain awake.  Dark wake technology differs from both full power mode and from sleep mode.  Using a dark wake approach,  the computer system powers up components necessary to maintain the network state, e.g., a CPU and a network interface. The computer system then renews the network state (e.g., renews an IP address lease from a DHCP server or other network connection) or otherwise updates a network state (e.g., sends/receives data to/from another networked device).  The computer system consumes more power than in sleep mode because of its use of a CPU/core and network interface, but is not required to resume a full power (awake) mode to maintain the network state or otherwise terminate the network state before or during a sleep state.  In short the server uses the power for only those components needed to maintain the network capability while not incurring power expense for the components that aren't.

Dark wake technology was patented by Apple under the USPTO Green Technology Pilot Program. US Patent 7,996,694 was granted on 08/09/11. To learn more about the energy efficiency patents granted under the Green Technology Pilot Program get the Green Tech Discover and Analysis Report.



Friday, September 7, 2012

Access to Knowledge - A Primer & Thought Leadership



Access to Knowledge in the Age of Intellectual Property edited by Gaëlle Krikorian and Amy Kapczynski — A discussion of how intellectual property and access to knowledge collide, intersect, and compete.

Access to Knowledge (A2K) is a term used to cover many of the issues that impact the changing world of digital knowledge — copyright, creative commons "copyleft" protection of traditional knowledge, patent rights intellectual property and trade.  A2K has many aspects and many constituencies.  Here the discussion brings into sharp contrast how intellectual property collides with everyday life.  This is the latest selection from the Way Better Patents Intellectual Property Reading List.

Consider some of the goings-on in the IP world.  Publishers of technical journals suing patent attorneys for making unauthorized (read uncompensated for) copies of their copyright protected work to attached to patent applications to document prior art.  College students who found cheap copies of expensive text books during their semester abroad and shipped them home to sell on eBay are now being sued by the publishers because they believe reselling a used book that was printed overseas in the US market violates their copyright.  Medical researchers attempting to patent treatments that use the same compounds documented in century old Sanskrit.

Access to Knowledge in the Age of Intellectual Property defines the core issues on how the digital world calls for new thinking on the issues and provides insightful thought leadership on the complex legal, regulatory, educational, and human issues.  I was introduced to the A2K folks as "progressive IP advocates."  The progressive moniker made me predisposed to think this was going to be a sermon on why patents are bad and why copyrighted works should be free for the taking.  You will be surprised at the discussion and how the authors have framed the discussion.  The progressive IP advocates have a lot to say.




Thursday, September 6, 2012

Government Interest Statements September 4th

Each week Way Better Patents publishes a list of the latest patents and patent applications that contain Government Interest Statements or include a Joint Research Agreement (JRA) statement.  The list includes the patent information, the assignees, the funding agency, and the actual statement which usually includes the contract numbers for federally funded research efforts.  The JRA statement usually identifies the parties working together on the intellectual property.

Here is a summary of granted patents that contain a government interest statement or a joint research agreement statements for September 4th, 2012.


41     Department of Defense (DOD)
30     Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
28     Department of Energy (DOE)
13     National Science Foundation (NSF)
10     National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
3     Department of Commerce (DOC)
2     Department of Agriculture (USDA)
1     Department of Homeland Security (DHS)
1     Department of Justice (DOJ)
1     Department of State (DOS)
1     National Geospatial Intelligence Agency (NGA)
1     National Security Agency (NSA)


patentECO Innovations - Agriculture

This post starts a short series that will highlight recent innovations in the patentECO Indexes. We will briefly review a couple of patents issued in each Index in 2012, starting with Agriculture.

Rice — Very Old Food, Very New Methods

Rice has been part of a staple diet for thousands of years. Historically grown using large amounts of water, including flooding of rice paddies, new methods of production are being developed to allow the grain to be grown in areas outside its historic geographic base, and to do so in ways that optimize the use of available water.

Inventors Jacob L. LaRue (Omaha, NE) and Germani Concenco (Uberaba, Brazil) apply new methods of clean tech rice production in patent US Patent 8,087,201 “Method for irrigating and fertilizing rice”, issued on January 3, 2012 and assigned to Valmont Industries, Inc. (Omaha, NE). They seek to both irrigate and fertilize rice using a sprinkler irrigation system. They determine the amount of water and fertilizer to be applied to the rice through the sprinkler irrigation system. Depending upon rainfall, the irrigation water may be applied to the rice an average of about one to two times per week between its planting and emergence, about two to three times per week between its emergence and its panicle initiation stage, about three to five times per week between its panicle initiation stage and its initial ripening stage, and about three to four times per week between the rice’s initial ripening stage and its harvest.

Clean tech aspects of their invention that meet our patentECO definitions include their recognition that “water shortages [are] becoming ever more frequent in many rice-producing regions around the world, [and] efforts have been made to explore other growing techniques in order to reduce the overall water requirements, improve production, and increase overall economic return … a need exists for a method of growing rice utilizing a sprinkler irrigation system wherein the irrigation applications are applied in amounts and at times to optimize the efficiency of the water applied. A need also exists for a method of growing rice utilizing a sprinkler irrigation system wherein fertilizer and pesticide are applied in amounts and at times optimal for curtailing unwanted weeds and other constraints to rice production.”

Claim 1 states:
"A method for irrigating and fertilizing rice using a sprinkler irrigation system, said method comprising the steps of:
providing a sprinkler irrigation system; 
determining an amount of water to be applied to the rice based on external factors; 
determining an amount of fertilizer to be applied to the rice based on external factors; 
applying water to the rice through said sprinkler irrigation system wherein, between a combination of irrigation water and rainwater, the rice receives an average of between about 6 and 25 mm of water per week between its planting and its emergence from the soil’s surface, an average of between about 13 and 75 mm of water per week between said emergence and its panicle initiation stage, an average of between about 19 and 102 mm of water per week between said panicle initiation stage and its initial ripening stage; 
and applying a fertilizer to the rice through said sprinkler irrigation system."

Improve the Crop — Protect the Seeds

Another important approach to improving agriculture in the clean tech arena focuses on yield enhancement. Harald Walter (Rodersdorf, Switzerland) and his co-inventors seek to improve crop yields at the seed stage, prior to planting. Patent US8198215, “Methods for protecting seeds” was issued June 12, 2012 and assigned to Sygenta Crop Protection LLC (Greensboro, NC). The invention provides a method of controlling phytopathogenic diseases on useful plants or plant propagation material by applying a fungicide incorporating trifluoromethyl or difluoromethyl, which they state is particularly effective in controlling or preventing fungal diseases of crop plants.

One of the clean tech aspects of their approach is by applying pesticides to crop seeds in a targeted way that addresses the need for reducing environmental and worker exposure compared to foliar or soil pesticide applications. They say that their method “is especially suitable to increase the yield and/or quality of useful plants, such as crop yield of crop plants.”

You can learn more about the patentECO sphere of clean tech at Way Better Patents.

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Green Tech Contraction


USPTO Green Technology Pilot Program Participants– Not Immune …

… to the sudden bankruptcies that seem to plague the “green energy” business.

International Battery, Inc. received five patents under the USPTO Green Technology Pilot Program prior to its closure in mid-February 2012. These patents (US7855011, US7931985, US8076026, US8092557, US8102642) generally dealt with lithium ion battery or ultracapacitor technology. IB filed a Petition to Make Special under the Greentech program for a sixth patent (US7875382, also for battery technology) but that petition was dismissed by USPTO. The company owned two other US patents for lithium ion battery technology, 7855011 and 7837745.

IB abruptly closed in early March 2012, citing its inability to earn a profit. About 60 jobs were eliminated with the closing. Its public relations firm stated that “While International Battery has a unique product and green manufacturing process, it has not been able to reach profitability. Unfortunately, given the challenging market, it was unable to raise additional capital to fund its operations.”

In common with all the other failed clean energy companies over the past few years, International Battery received significant loan guarantees. According to an article in the March 13, 2012 Morning Call, the company received almost $3 million in loans and grants from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

Way Better Patents believes that “Inventions in the clean tech patent ecosystem, when brought to market, have economic features of offering competitive returns for investors, competitive prices for consumers, and realistic profits for producers.” (emphasis added)

For some USPTO Green Tech Pilot Program participants, accelerated examination hasn’t helped them overcome the economic contraction in the green technology renewable power marketplace.

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Carbon Dioxide Reduction - Different Strokes for Different Folks


On August 1, 2012 the US Energy Information Administration stated that
"U.S. carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions resulting from energy use during the first quarter of 2012 were the lowest in two decades for any January-March period. Normally, CO2 emissions during the year are highest in the first quarter because of strong demand for heat produced by fossil fuels. However, CO2 emissions during January-March 2012 were low due to a combination of three factors:
  • A mild winter that reduced household heating demand and therefore energy use
  • A decline in coal-fired electricity generation, due largely to historically low natural gas prices
  • Reduced gasoline demand."
Their news release went on to say that “The decline in coal-related emissions is due mainly to utilities using less coal for electricity generation as they burned more low-priced natural gas … Natural gas is the least carbon-intensive fossil fuel, producing the lowest CO2 emissions.”

In this post we’ll look at two Air Index patents issued in 2012. In reviewing these, I’m reminded of the chorus from the song "Let’s Call The Whole Thing Off" by the great Ella Fitzgerald and Satchmo (Louis Armstrong for some of you):
"You say eether and I say eyether,
You say neether and I say nyther,
Eether, eyether, neether, nyther,
Let’s call the whole thing off!
You like potato and I like potahto,
You like tomato and I like tomahto,
Potato, potahto, tomato, tomahto!
Let’s call the whole thing off!"
There are many ways to reduce carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere, and these two patents illustrate widely different approaches. One actually reduces emissions, the second – not so much.

Reducing CO2 in offshore natural gas

Daniel Chinn (Bay Point, CA) and a team of co-inventors were granted US 8,192,524, “Process for upgrading natural gas with improved management of CO2” on June 5, 2012; their patent is assigned to Chevron U.S.A. Inc.
Chinn et al. state the problem they are attempting to solve:
”Offshore gas fields in many parts of the world produce natural gas containing a significant amount of carbon dioxide (e.g. greater than 10 vol % CO2). For example, the CO2 content of natural gas streams originating offshore can be as high as 80 vol %. 
In contrast, at onshore locations where natural gas is to be used, the natural gas should generally have a relatively low CO2 content. For example, a lower CO2content corresponds to a higher heating value for the natural gas. CO2 can also lead to freezing in the low-temperature chillers in liquified natural gas (LNG) plants. 
There are two main approaches to upgrading natural gas offshore. The first approach involves blending the gas with sufficiently low CO2 gas to reduce the overall CO2 content. The second, alternative approach involves subjecting the gas to some type of CO2 removal process. 
… there is a need for a process for producing a CO2-depleted product gas stream from natural gas containing a significant amount of carbon dioxide (e.g. greater than 10 vol % CO2). Such process should require minimal equipment weight and energy and take up minimal space. Moreover, such process should exhibit minimal hydrocarbon losses to the CO2-rich permeate. Accordingly, such process will be useful for upgrading natural gas offshore, will be profitable, and will result in minimal GHG [greenhouse gas] emissions.”
They achieve their goal by using a polymer membrane filtration process in which a natural gas feed stream comprising water vapor and greater than about 10 vol % CO2 is passed to a membrane unit. The membranes are selectively permeable to CO2, allowing it to be separated from the natural gas and, according to the patent, “disposed of in any manner known in the art.” In other words, their invention separates the carbon dioxide, it’s up to you to get rid of it.

The drawing for this invention, which illustrates this post, is fully in keeping with the sterile line drawings that we have come to expect from modern patents, and is one of the least meaningful ones that we’ve run across in the universe of clean and green technology.

Emissions Trading, or Sales?

The second patent in today’s lineup is, according to the USPTO, primarily a business method – a clean tech (or green tech, if you prefer) business method invention, with a slight flavoring of hazardous or toxic waste destruction or containment. US 8,126,780, “Method for cultured sea algae” was issued to Katsumi Iwai and Hiroshi Horibata, both of Tokyo, Japan, on February 28, 2012.

Iwai and Horibata seek to provide a “method and apparatus for utilizing, processing, distributing and an accompanying business model for sea algae, particularly forced cultured kombu, to prevent the expansion of global warming, by encouraging a re-purchase of the cultured sea algae, by paying the purchaser back, in a constant rate, a part of the profit from the sales of a CO2 omission [sic] right, which right depends upon the CO2 absorption and fixation ability.”
From Wikipedia:
”Kombu (昆布 in Japanese, and 海带 in Chinese, Saccharina japonica and others), several Pacific species of kelp, is a very important ingredient in Chinese, Japanese, and Korean cuisines. Kombu is used to flavor broths and stews (especially dashi), as a savory garnish (tororo konbu) for rice and other dishes, as a vegetable, and a primary ingredient in popular snacks (such as tsukudani). Transparent sheets of kelp (oboro konbu) are used as an edible decorative wrapping for rice and other foods. Kombu can be used to soften beans during cooking, and to help convert indigestible sugars and thus reduce flatulence.”
Both natural and cultured kombu beds are harvested.
So how does a business method patent about cultured kelp help to reduce atmospheric emissions of carbon dioxide?
Claim 1 states:
A method for cultured algae comprising: 
storing, in a computer data base, records of culturing conditions, yield, and carbon fixation volumes for a sea algae culturing facility of a predetermined scale in a specific sea area; 
obtaining, via a remote sensing device configured to perform at least one of space satellite remote sensing, under water remote sensing, and direct artificial sensing, data pertaining to actual culturing conditions, yield, and carbon fixation volumes associated with the sea algae culturing facility; 
storing, in a computer data base, the data obtained pertaining to the actual culturing conditions, yield, and carbon fixation volumes; 
comparing the obtained data pertaining to the actual culturing conditions, yield, and carbon fixation volumes to the stored records of culturing conditions, yield and carbon fixation volumes of the sea algae culturing facility; 
computing a weight of cultured sea algae and a carbon fixation quantity from the obtained data and certifying the computed carbon fixation quantity in the presence of a third party; 
calculating a greenhouse gas omission [sic] right based on the certified carbon fixation quantity and the computed weight of the cultured sea algae; 
selling the greenhouse gas omission [sic] right through a global warming gas omission [sic] right trading mechanism; 
processing at least a portion of the cultured sea algae to produce a product, the product including at least one of a food article, an industrial article, and an agriculture-forestry-marine article; 
and distributing, via a market, the product produced from processing at least a portion of the cultured sea algae.
Kelp, an algae, is a plant. Plants convert carbon dioxide (in this case CO2 dissolved in ocean water) to sugar through the photosynthetic process. They absorb CO2 and fix it in sugar stored in their cells. In a nutshell (or maybe thallus since we are discussing kelp), this patent would calculate the amount of carbon dioxide fixed as sugars in the harvested cultured kelp, certify that computation “in the presence of a third party”, calculate a greenhouse gas omission [sic] (note to USPTO: your examiners should do a better job of correcting important errors such as substituting the word ‘omission’ for ‘emission’ in their correspondence with inventors.) ‘right’, sell that ‘right’ “through a global warming gas omission [sic] right trading mechanism” (will Al Gore get a cut? Where has Al Gore been during this very hot, stormy, and drought-ridden summer, by the way?), and processing the kelp and distributing the product to market.

Note that nothing in this patent actually reduces atmospheric CO2 emissions, it merely provides a mechanism to separate people from their money so they can feel good about having saved the planet from global warming.

Kelp growers/harvesters/processors establish omission [sic] rights? This is an entirely new one to me.

You really owe it to yourself to read through this patent, particularly the Background of the Invention and the Brief Description of Disclosed Invention sections (which constitute a the first major part of the patent “Specification”).

Monday, September 3, 2012

A Successful Clean Tech Failure


An article in my local newspaper points to the success that the free market, if allowed to work, can have to weed out non-viable renewable energy projects.

An article entitled “Too Little of Litter” in the Harrisonburg (VA) Daily News Record describes the recent decision of Fibrowatt LLC to abandon plans to build a poultry litter-to-energy plant here in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley.

The Commonwealth of Virginia had undertaken a feasibility study of the proposal, but stopped it in June 2012 after learning that Valley poultry operations produce about 345,000 tons of litter per year, in contrast to Fibrowatt’s estimates of close to 500,000 tons annually.

Fibrowatt had originally proposed in 2010 constructing a 40–55 megawatt litter-to-energy plant in Page County, Virginia, but very heavy local opposition to the project led the company to abandon that area as a potential site; they did not subsequently name an alternative location.

The Virginia Tech study by Dr. Jim Pease found, in addition to providing more realistic estimates of annual Valley litter production, that “demand for litter as a fertilizer in the central Valley exceeds the current supply … [f]armers would have to spend more than $13 million collectively to replace the litter needed for fertilizer that would be lost to the plant’s fuel needs,” according to today’s news article.

This is a successful clean tech failure. Market factors and local opposition were used by Fibrowatt in its decision to abandon the project. Government incentives (e.g., loan guarantees, grants, favorable tax rates, infrastructure support) were not lost by a business that went bankrupt. Taxpayers were not left holding the bag. Government agencies were not involved in choosing renewable energy winners and losers.

The market worked, as it can and should if allowed. Kudos to Fibrowatt for making an appropriate business decision, and to state and local officials for not spending taxpayer funds on a project for which there were insufficient raw materials.

Learn more about clean tech innovation.