Wednesday, February 27, 2013
But Does It Create Energy?
Monday, February 25, 2013
Renewables in the Sky
Renewable energy generation at the utility scale in the US was derived from multiple sources in 2011. Hydropower was the largest source (63% of renewable energy) followed by wind (23%). Solar power contributed less than one percent of renewable energy that year. Renewables as a whole represented 13% of the overall electricity generation mix, according to figures from the US Energy Information Administration. Renewable energy sources are well-known in the transportation industry (e.g., electric vehicles, hybrid gas-electric vehicles, natural gas vehicles, fuel cells, etc.). Efforts are underway to develop biofuels for the aviation industry.
Not to be forgotten are proponents of solar energy that hope to develop and demonstrate solar-powered airplanes.
The Invention
US Patent 8,002,216, “Solar powered wing vehicle using flywheels for energy storage,” was issued to inventor Darwin Kent Decker in August 2011. His patent is for “[a] solar powered air vehicle that can stay aloft for indefinite periods of time. The vehicle employs photovoltaic solar cells for primary power and high speed counter-rotating flywheels for energy storage and steering of the vehicle. The flywheels are placed in the wing to reduce airfoil drag. A control law provides three-axis stabilized control of the vehicle by controlling propeller pitch to vary the speeds of the flywheels.” His purpose for the solar flying wing clearly falls within the clean tech realm:
”With the threat of global warming and increasing gasoline prices, the interest in solar powered aircraft using photovoltaic solar cells has increased.”
Advantages of a solar-powered plane include:
”… it can stay aloft for indefinite periods that may extend into years of time similar to the operation of a satellite. Further, the solar powered aircraft can perform many of the present functions of a satellite without the cost of an expensive launch vehicle and without eventually creating orbital waste. The solar powered aircraft can return to earth for maintenance and be re-configured for a variety of missions. Typical applications include surveillance and tracking, homeland security, communications, oceanography, and meteorology. Many of these applications require operation at high altitudes greater than 60,000 feet where air breathing engine are less efficient.”
He notes that:
”A more appropriate energy storage device [i.e, than batteries or fuel cells] for use with long life solar powered airplanes is a high speed flywheel with a composite rotor and magnetic bearings. High speed flywheels provide superior energy per unit weight than batteries in applications where long cycle life is required. Composite rotors have demonstrated over 112,000 cycles in laboratory tests. Furthermore, flywheels provide a more efficient energy to thrust ratio for this application than batteries since batteries store energy chemically. Converting electrical energy to chemical energy, then back to electrical energy and then to rotational energy is inherently less efficient than converting the electrical energy directly to rotational energy in the flywheels and then using torque conversion to apply the energy directly to rotating propellers. Furthermore, flywheels produce moments and gyroscopic couples that can be used to steer the aircraft and eliminate or reduce the need for additional steering devices such as flaps, fuselage and a tail section that create additional drag on the vehicle. To date, flywheel energy storage has not been used in solar powered air vehicles.”

Note the similarity of the body structure of the ‘216 patent to that of the Northrup XB–35 flying wing from the 1940s.
Other Renewable Energy in Aircraft?
Decker proposes to use solar power. Various companies, including Amyris Biotechnologies (see our 1/12/12 post linked above), are developing aviation biofuels. What about wind power?
Interestingly, the earliest patent cited by Decker in the ‘216 patent is US 1,245,902, issued in November 1917 to Frank Gretsky of Coal Center, PA. His invention “Aeroplane motor” had the object of providing,
“a simple, practical and efficient attachment of strong, durable and comparatively inexpensive construction comprising a wind wheel adapted to be mounted on the propeller shaft and connected with the same by a train of gears so that the wind from the propeller, or resulting therefrom by the passage of the aeroplane through the air, will act on the wind wheel and assist in rotating the same and thereby effect a saving of fuel.
A further object of this invention is to provide a motor of this character adapted, in event of the internal combustion engine of the aeroplane becoming inoperative while the aeroplane is in the air, to serve as a wind motor for actuating the propeller and thereby rendering the aeroplane more easily handled and comparatively safe under such conditions.”
Gretsky was awarded a patent for mounting a windmill on an airplane to aid in, or wholly provide, its propulsion, and his intent in 1917 was to save fuel using wind power. Once again, we see that clean tech is not new, and our forebears were no less interested in energy savings, renewable energy and conservation than we are.
A Third-Generation Explorer Counts on The Sun
Bertrand Piccard is now a decade in to his Solar Impulse project that seeks to develop solar-powered planes. The Solar Impulse plane will be conducting test flights at NASA’s Moffett Field in May, and then is planned for a demo cross-country flight to Washington DC and New York. Piccard ultimately hopes to fly the plane around the world. The plane, a single-seater, has a 208-feet wingspan (equivalent to an Airbus A340), weighs a little more than 3,500 pounds, and is powered by four 10-horsepower electric motors. It will store electricity in lithium polymer batteries during the day for use during night flight. The plane’s upper wing surface and horizontal stabilizer house 11,628 solar cells.
These cells are manufactured by SunPower, one of the solar companies receiving patents under the USPTO Green Technology Pilot Program. Although this is a high-profile opportunity for SunPower, it has not been without its troubles in a turbulent solar market.
Piccard is the third generation of a family of noted explorers. His grandfather Auguste Piccard was a balloonist that established world records for high altitude balloon flight (a predecessor of Felix Baumgartner’s amazing flight last October on the anniversary of Chuck Yeager’s breaking the speed of sound). Piccard’s father, Jacques Piccard, was the first submariner (along with his dive companion Don Walsh) to reach the Challenger Deep in the Pacific Ocean’s Mariana Trench. They used the submersible Trieste to descend to 35,797 feet below the ocean’s surface on January 23, 1960. The Trieste was designed by Jacques’ father Auguste. The Challenger Deep was not re-visited by humans until March 2012 when the film-maker James Cameron reached the deepest point on earth in the Deepsea Challenger. Bertrand Piccard fulfilled Jules Vernes’ dream expressed in “Around the World in Eighty Days” when he co-piloted the first non-stop circumglobal balloon flight. Fascinating articles on all three men may be found in back issues of National Geographic magazine. A good article on Solar Impulse was recently published by Gigaom.
Clean technologies and renewable energy are being applied to aviation - but they have been for a long time.
End Note:
Gretsky’s windmill-on-a-plane, 1917. We’ve written it before, but the old patent drawings are art, unlike the sterile CAD depictions in today’s patents. It is not progress when aesthetics and beauty are abandoned.
Labels:
aviation clean tech,
Bertrand Piccard,
flying wing,
solar-powered planes,
SoloarImpulse,
Wayfinder Digital
Friday, February 22, 2013
Patent Resources -- US Patent Classification Glossary
US Patent Classification Glossary -- An alphabetical list of the definitions of terms of art that appear within the body of the US Patent Classification system class definitions.
The US Patent Classification (USPC) system includes definitions of key terms relevant to the definition of the types of inventions included in the classification.
USPTO uses these words to define what the specific term means in the context of the classifications. These are terms of art — a term that has a specialized meaning in a particular chemical, electrical, or mechanical scientific or engineering domain. Within the current US Patent Classification system a word can have a different meaning depending on the area of invention that it resides in. There are three different definitions for the word "Active" — one that pertains to pharmacology and biology; one that relates to plant growth; and a third that deals with an "active database." There are five definitions of "Acylic", three for "Address Data"; five for "Alkali Metals."
Way Better Patents' data wizards pulled all of the definitions from all of the classes that had definitions and assembled them into one alphabetical collection. You can click the link and find the definition as it appears in the Class description.
The advantage of this presentation is that you can see what all three instances of the term "Address Data" mean and then click the link to the actual class definition of the one you think is most important to you and explore what it means. It also helps people new to researching patents understand the impact of how different terms are used within different domains. This becomes important when you are researching inventions where technology is converging - a medical device with a software component, or a smoke detecting cell phone for example.
The legend below will help you to navigate to the alphabetical list of terms.
| A | B | C-CL | CM-CZ | D-DIM | DIM-DZ | E | F | G | H | I | J-K | L | M-MET | MET-MZ | N | O | P-PHA | PHE-PON | POR-PZ | Q | R | S-SEPA | SEPO-SMT | SN-STEM | STEP-SZ | T-TOG | TON-TZ | U | V | W | X-Z |
Way Better Patents has a variety of patent information tools designed to make information about patents more accessible and easier to understand. From time to time we post updates on these tools here.
(So far we haven't heard anything about how these in situ (a patentesque word meaning in place) will be reflected in the nascent Cooperative Patent Classification system (CPC) but it's still good to understand the different meaning of different words when they are used within the definition of particular classes of art (groups of inventions) at USPTO.)
Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Fracking Fluids #1
There has been a recent flurry of media attention on Halliburton’s ‘CleanStim’ hydraulic fracturing (aka ‘fracking’, fracing’, or ‘hydrofracking’) fluid that the company says is derived from food industry products. Halliburton’s CleanStim fluid was actually released for use in 2010. What is the purpose of frack fluid? What’s in it?
Hydraulic fracturing uses large volumes of extremely high pressure fluid injected deep below the ground to create fractures in the oil- or gas-bearing rock formation. These fractures are kept (propped) open with a “proppant” (or “propping agent”) - often a silica sand - allowing the hydrocarbons to flow from the formation to the well-bore. There have been many innovations in hydraulic fracturing. These past posts spot light several inventions and the patents that support them..
The fracking fluid contains major groups of chemicals that serve specific functions needed to achieve successful and efficient recovery of the underground hydrocarbons. A gelling agent or hydration aid reduces friction of the overall mixture with the well-site piping and well-bore by modifying the viscosity of the fluid. Biocides are used to control bacteria growth, thereby maintaining the integrity of the fluid, and the health of the formation. A crosslinker increases the viscoelasticity of the fracturing fluid, thereby improving proppant transport and distribution within the fractures created in the formation. Crosslinkers create a chemical bond link between the polymer chains used in the gel. Breakers work in opposition to crosslinkers - they reduce viscoelasticity and viscosity by breaking the polymer chain links and are used in cleanup of the fracture system. Surfactants (think soap or detergent) enhance recovery of the hydrocarbons by reducing their surface tension with the formation rock.
(A more user friendly version of the fracking fluids tables below are available at Way Better Patents.)
The US Department of Energy reported several years ago that a typical fracking fluid is composed by volume of:
The exact blend of a frack fluid varies based on well-specific conditions, source water characteristics, and the vendor product used, and the individual treatments will use from 3–12 of the additives besides water and the propping agent. The purpose of the individual components is listed in the following table here.
Source: Modern Shale Gas Development in the United States: A Primer. USDOE, NETL. 2009.
How do the ingredients of Halliburton’s CleanStim fracking fluid compare to the generic list above?
Source: http://www.halliburton.com/public/projects/pubsdata/Hydraulic_Fracturing/CleanSuite_Technologies.html#
In part 2 we’ll look at some fracking fluid inventions from Halliburton and other companies that are intended to address concerns about potential environmental and human health effects of frack fluid constituents.
Frack Fluid, Briefly
Hydraulic fracturing uses large volumes of extremely high pressure fluid injected deep below the ground to create fractures in the oil- or gas-bearing rock formation. These fractures are kept (propped) open with a “proppant” (or “propping agent”) - often a silica sand - allowing the hydrocarbons to flow from the formation to the well-bore. There have been many innovations in hydraulic fracturing. These past posts spot light several inventions and the patents that support them..
The fracking fluid contains major groups of chemicals that serve specific functions needed to achieve successful and efficient recovery of the underground hydrocarbons. A gelling agent or hydration aid reduces friction of the overall mixture with the well-site piping and well-bore by modifying the viscosity of the fluid. Biocides are used to control bacteria growth, thereby maintaining the integrity of the fluid, and the health of the formation. A crosslinker increases the viscoelasticity of the fracturing fluid, thereby improving proppant transport and distribution within the fractures created in the formation. Crosslinkers create a chemical bond link between the polymer chains used in the gel. Breakers work in opposition to crosslinkers - they reduce viscoelasticity and viscosity by breaking the polymer chain links and are used in cleanup of the fracture system. Surfactants (think soap or detergent) enhance recovery of the hydrocarbons by reducing their surface tension with the formation rock.
(A more user friendly version of the fracking fluids tables below are available at Way Better Patents.)
The US Department of Energy reported several years ago that a typical fracking fluid is composed by volume of:
| Constituent | Percent by volume |
|---|---|
| Water & sand | 99.51% |
| Acid | 0.123% |
| Friction reducer | 0.088% |
| Surfactant | 0.085% |
| Potassium chloride | 0.06% |
| Gelling agent | 0.056% |
| Scale inhibitor | 0.043% |
| pH adjusting agent | 0.011% |
| Breaker | 0.01% |
| Crosslinker | 0.007% |
| Iron control | 0.004% |
| Corrosion inhibitor | 0.002% |
| Biocide | 0.001% |
The exact blend of a frack fluid varies based on well-specific conditions, source water characteristics, and the vendor product used, and the individual treatments will use from 3–12 of the additives besides water and the propping agent. The purpose of the individual components is listed in the following table here.
| Additive type | Common Compound(s) | Purpose | Common Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diluted Acid (15%) | Hydrochloric acid or muriatic acid | Help dissolve minerals and initiate cracks in the rock | Swimming pool chemical and cleaner |
| Biocide | Glutaraldehyde | Eliminates bacteria in the water that produce corrosive byproducts | Disinfectant; sterilize medical and dental equipment |
| Breaker | Ammonium persulfate | Allows a delayed break down of the gel polymer chains | Bleaching agent in detergent and hair cosmetics, manufacture of household plastics |
| Corrosion Inhibitor | N,n-dimethyl formamide | Prevents the corrosion of the pipe | Used in pharmaceuticals, acrylic fibers, plastics |
| Crosslinker | Borate salts | Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases | Laundry detergents, hand soaps, and cosmetics |
| Friction Reducer | Polyacrylamide; Mineral oil | Minimizes friction between the fluid and the pipe | Water treatment, soil conditioner; Make-up remover, laxatives, and candy |
| Gel | Guar gum or hydroxyethyl cellulose | Thickens the water in order to suspend the sand | Cosmetics, toothpaste, sauces, baked goods, ice cream |
| Iron Control | Citric acid | Prevents precipitation of metal oxides | Food additive, flavoring in food and beverages; Lemon Juice ~7% Citric Acid |
| KCl | Potassium chloride | Creates a brine carrier fluid | Low sodium table salt substitute |
| Oxygen Scavenger | Ammonium bisulfite | Removes oxygen from the water to protect the pipe from corrosion | Cosmetics, food and beverage processing, water treatment |
| pH Adjusting Agent | Sodium or potassium carbonate | Maintains the effectiveness of other components, such as crosslinkers | Washing soda, detergents, soap, water softener, glass and ceramics |
| Proppant | Silica, quartz sand | Allows the fractures to remain open so the gas can escape | Drinking water filtration, play sand, concrete, brick mortar |
| Scale Inhibitor | Ethylene glycol | Prevents scale deposits in the pipe | Automotive antifreeze, household cleansers, and de-icing agent |
| Surfactant | Isopropanol | Used to increase the viscosity of the fracture fluid | Glass cleaner, antiperspirant, and hair color |
Source: Modern Shale Gas Development in the United States: A Primer. USDOE, NETL. 2009.
How do the ingredients of Halliburton’s CleanStim fracking fluid compare to the generic list above?
| CleanStim Constituent | Common Uses |
|---|---|
| Enzyme | Soybean Paste, Fruit Juices and Nectars, Laundry Detergent, Dishwasher Detergent, Toilet Cleaner, Industrial Pulp and Paper Processing Aid |
| Ethoxylated Sugar-Based Fatty Acid Ester | Synthetic Food Flavoring Substance, Natural Baby Wipes, Baby Wash and Shampoo |
| Inorganic Acid | Cheese, Alcoholic Beverages, Wheel Cleaner, Rust Dissolver, Dishwashing Detergent |
| Inorganic Salt | Food Starch – Modified, Water Clarifier, Fish Tank Water Treatment |
| Maltodextrin | Sweetener, Glaze and Icing Sugar, Coconut Milk and Coconut Cream, Shower Gel |
| Organic Acid | Fruit Juice, Dishwasher Cleaner, All-Purpose Cleaner, Hand Soap |
| Organic Ester | Liquid Egg Products, Food Resinous and Polymeric Coatings, Hairspray |
| Partially Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil | Confectionary Chocolate Coating, Hair Detangler, Body Lotion, Lip Liner, Soap, Lotion, Cream and Other Skin Care Formulations |
| Polysaccharide Polymer | Canned Fish, Processed Cheese, Dairy-Based Desserts and Drinks, Beer, Toothpaste |
| Sulfonated Alcohol | Egg White Solids, Marshmallows, Dishwashing Liquid, Home Dilutable Cleaner, Shampoo, Acne Scrub, Shaving Cream, Liquid Hand Soap |
In part 2 we’ll look at some fracking fluid inventions from Halliburton and other companies that are intended to address concerns about potential environmental and human health effects of frack fluid constituents.
Monday, February 18, 2013
Taxpayer Subsidized Green Beer
![]() |
| Spent brewing grain. Source: blog.syracuse.com |
It's not St. Patrick’s Day yet but it's time to take a look at renewable energy, federal grants, and green beer.
A flurry of recent media attention was paid to the Alaskan Brewing Company (ABC), which has installed a new $1.8 million boiler that uses spent brewing grain as the fuel. The company is using the new boiler for its grain drying process, and for some of its process steam. ABC anticipates a 150,000 gallon annual savings in fuel oil by burning its spent grain.
Commentary on the project were uniformly lauding this as a new advance in combustion technology and brewing science. Like many green technologies being adopted under green technology agendas, the innovations aren't really new. Consider these inventions, some of which are over 20 years old.
Process and apparatus for incinerating wet refuse
US patent 5,010,830 issued to Masahiro Asuka (Ube, Japan) and co-inventors in April 1991. Assigned to Japan’s Ube Industries, Inc., the patent provides,
"An apparatus to be applicable as a boiler for incinerating wet refuse in a combustion chamber with a fluid and heat medium of solid particles fluidized by an air feed to form a fluidized bed, with the aid of combustion of auxiliary fuel effected below the fluidized bed, is provided with additional one or more adjacent upper fluidized fed chambers in series to have the wet refuse dried and partially incinerated in the lower primary fluidized bed chamber with the balance of the refuse in a form of unburnt carbon particles being forced to fly upward into the additional upper fluidized bed chambers and be incinerated therein. Heat recovery is carried out from a topmost fluidized bed chamber."
The Background of the Invention states that the “term ‘wet refuse’ as used herein refers mainly to manufacturing waste expelled from food production plants; for example, waste materials from barley and hops used by breweries, so called ‘beer dregs’, or coffee grounds, orange pulp or tea leaves expelled from a canning plant involved. These plants also emit sludge and other waste products which fall into the category of ‘wet matter’, and these products are treated in a similar manner. The generated heat energy is utilized in the same way as that of a boiler or the like.”
Waste incineration heat conversion system
Also from Japan, Toshiko Fukushima and co-inventors were granted US 5,678,420 in October 1997. The patent was assigned to Hitachi, Ltd. It provides for,
"A waste incineration heat conversion system has an incinerator for burning waste discharged from an installation, a heat recovering section for recovering the heat generated by combustion of the waste in the incinerator, a cold generating section for generating cold by utilizing the thus recovered heat, and a pipe line for conveying the thus generated cold to the installation so that the thus conveyed cold is utilized in the installation for a purpose."
The Summary of the Invention explains that the “combustible waste discharged from the installation is incinerated by the waste burning means of the system of the invention to generate heat which is directly or indirectly recovered by the heat recovering means as a thermal energy. รข€¦ The installation may be a brewing plant and the combustible waste may comprise combustible brewer’s grains and sludge discharged from the brewing plant.”
Process for thermally utilizing spent grains
Not to be outdone, Austrian inventor Leopold Werner Kepplinger and his team were granted US 6,167,636 in January 2001. Brau-Union Osterreich Aktiengesselschaft was assigned this patent, which claims,
"a process for thermally utilizing wet spent grains (1), the wet spent grains (1) are mechanically predried in a first drying stage (2), thermally dried in a further drying stage (4) and finally thermally utilized by burning or gasification. In order to be able to realize a process of this kind economically, the mechanically dehydrated spent grains (15) in the further drying stage (4) are heated by the aid of a smoke gas occurring within the energy system of a brewery."
The patent specification teaches the following:
"When producing beer, the wet spent grains, or brewing draff, which occur in large quantities, constitute a problem of disposal and utilization. About 20 kg of wet spent grains occur per hectoliter beer such that large-scale breweries have to dispose of, or utilize, hundreds of tons of spent grains per week."
Due to their composition, spent grains constitute a valuable fodder; it is, however, difficult to use the spent grains as a fodder in a cost-effective manner. The proper time for selling same as a fodder without problems is in winter–on the other hand, spent grains occur in larger quantities in summer than in winter. Moreover, spent grains cannot be stored without predrying. Drying is expensive, since only indirect drying is possible due to the demands set on fodder; which means poor heat transmission. Appropriate driers are expensive, involving high energy expenditures.
Apparatus and method for resource recovery from organic substance
Back to the Japanese. Hiromu Shishido and Norio Omoda obtained US 6,474,067 in November 2002; it is assigned to Chugoku Maintenance Co., Ltd. of Hiroshima, Japan. A more advanced invention:
"In a gasification furnace, a combustible gas is generated from an organic substance for gasification containing biomass of organic wastes or the like. An engine of a cogeneration is operated using this combustible gas to generate electricity by an electric generator driven by the engine, and hot water is generated by heating water in a radiator. The hot water is heated by a superheated steam generator of a heat storage type utilizing the electric power from the electric generator to generate superheated steam. Furthermore, a dry-distilled gas and a carbide are generated by dry-distilling and carbonizing an organic substance for carbonization containing biomass of organic wastes or the like with this superheated steam in the carbonization furnace. Thus, the resources are recovered from the organic substances containing biomass of organic wastes or the like by gasifying or carbonizing the organic substances with the superheated steam."
It can be applied to a wide range of organic fuels as described in claim 20:
"the organic substance for carbonization heated in the carbonization step is at least one selected from the group consisting of agricultural wastes including chaff and straw, livestock wastes including fowl droppings and droppings of pigs and cattle, forestry wastes including lumber from thinning, waste wood and bamboo, industrial wastes discharged in a food production process, a brew process or a lumber production process, domestic wastes including food refuse, domestic garbage and waste edible oil, organic resources, waste rubber materials and resins including fiber reinforced resins."
Method for thermal processing of a slurry and biomass
Not to be left out is German inventor Jurgen Buchert, whose patent US 7,799,960 was issued in September 2010; Buchert retained ownership. He envisions an electricity-producing system:
"In a method and apparatus for thermal processing of slurry, the slurry is combined with a bio-mass to produce a mixture which is then subjected to a cracking temperature in a receiving tank, thereby liquefying and allowing the mixture to catalytically undergo a cracking reaction. The cracking reaction which the liquefied mixture undergoes is continued in a mixer pump to thereby produce a reaction mixture. The reaction mixture is outgased in an intermediate tank to separate an outgased fraction from a non-outgased fraction. Subsequently, the outgased fraction is allowed to cool down, thereby producing fuel, while the non-outgased fraction is returned to the receiving tank and subjected again to the cracking temperature. Residual matter of the non-outgased fraction settles in the intermediate tank and is periodically removed."
Further, “the bio-mass may be biological waste material, e.g. rape residues or wood residues, e.g. sawdust, sugar beet residues, husks obtained during beer brewing or liquor production, animal meal, cellulose from paper production, press cake from feedstock production for animals, straw and the like, as well as other substances, such as various grains, corn, etc.”
Process for a disposal of waste solutions
Not only can breweries use their spent grain for boiler fuel, steam generation, or electricity generation, they can also build their facility with it according to Hugh Bogle and Charles Buchanan of Sarasota, FL and Nazareth, PA, respectively. Their patent, US 4,571,175, issued in February 1986 and was assigned to Roan Industries, Inc. They use spent grain in cement:
"A method of disposing of aqueous waste in which the aqueous waste is mixed with cement raw materials to form a slurry for the preparation of Portland cement or the like, for example in a rotary kiln. Prior to forming the slurry, the aqueous waste is treated to remove volatiles and other pollutants which vaporize when heated to a temperature below the boiling point of water. Such volatile materials are removed by contacting the aqueous waste with the effluent exhaust gases from the kiln itself and with the effluent air from the clinker cooler with suitable controls to avoid loss of the water component of the aqueous waste through boiling. The treated aqueous waste is then embodied in the slurry fed to the kiln and the pollutants in the water which can be combusted by the high temperature in the kiln are destroyed. The gaseous effluent which is cooled by contact with the aqueous waste may be discharged or further treated to recover the volatiles and other components which may be salvaged."
The aqueous waste? “One example of a waste solution is brewery waste which not only includes ethyl alcohol, but also is extremely odoriferous because of the yeast, malt and alcohol contained in it.”
Why Are US Tax Dollars Paying For This?
An Alaskan Brewing Company executive was quoted as saying that “Reducing our energy use makes good business sense” If it makes good business sense, why do you need a federal grant to the tune of $450,000?
It's unclear why, given current economic conditions and the fact that the Alaskan Brewing Company is achieving a significant cost savings why USDA is funding this type of a project.
The web page for USDA’s Rural Energy for America Program explains,
"REAP creates opportunities for economic development for rural businesses by supporting renewable energy and energy efficiency projects, via loan guarantees and grants. The program provides assistance to qualified applicants to finance renewable energy (renewable biomass, anaerobic digesters, geothermal for electric generation, geothermal for direct use, hydroelectric (30 megawatts or less), hydrogen, small and large wind, small and large solar and ocean (including tidal, wave, current, and thermal) and energy efficiency projects. It expands the existing private credit structure by providing a credit enhancement via a loan guarantee."
It's surprising that this technology hasn't been more widely adopted and that it takes federal funding to get inventions like these into production. The question is what will the taxpayers return in investment be.
These technologies can be found in Way Better Patents’ Energy Index.
Labels:
alternative fuels,
clean combustion technology,
patentECO,
renewable energy,
spent brewing grain
Thursday, February 14, 2013
Author Obfuscation in the Patentsphere
The Winter 2013 edition of Journal of Economic Perspectives features an article called , "Of Smart Phone Wars and Software Patents" written by Stuart Graham and Saurabh Vishnubhakat.
According to the abstract, "Principally, the article highlights how the US Patent Office acts responsibly when it engages constructively with principled criticisms and calls for reform as it has during the passage and now implementation of the landmark Leahy-Smith America Invents Act of 2011."
Fundamentally this is an articles designed to show that software patents aren't handled any differently at USPTO than other patents. The authors select a group of patent classifications to define software patents and use the behavior of the patents in comparison with other non-software patents to illustrate that the USPTO outcomes are similar.
(We could make the argument that if we shifted the Classes included in the paper here and there, that the outcome might be different. It is also curious that after the big build up to the new Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC) system by USPTO, that the authors didn't elect to use the new classifications in their article. But we digress.)
But there is something very curious here. Who are the authors?
The articles bibliographic information about the authors says,
"Stuart J. H. Graham is an Expert Advisor to the US Patent and Trademark Office. He is an Assistant Professor, Scheller College of Busines, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia and is an attorney licensed in the State of New York. Saurabh Vishnubhakat is an Expert Advisor at the US Patent and Trademark Office. He is an Adjunct Professor at the Norther Virginia Community College, Alexandria, Virginia and is licensed in the State of Illinois."
Expert Advisors to the USPTO and academics. Well, not quite.
Stuart Graham is the Chief Economist at USPTO. Or as noted on the USPTO website, "The USPTO established the Office of the Chief Economist (OCE) in March 2010, with the appointment of Dr. Stuart Graham as its first Chief Economist. The Chief Economist is responsible for advising the Under Secretary and the Administrator for External Affairs on the economic implications of policies and programs affecting the United States intellectual property system. The Chief Economist initiates and oversees groundbreaking economic analysis in the field on the topics of intellectual property protection and enforcement, with the object of fulfilling the USPTO’s statutory obligation to provide the President (through the Secretary of Commerce) and the Administration with advice on intellectual property policy." Dr. Graham has a considerable research agenda at USPTO and is the public fact of many of the Office's outreach efforts including encouraging colleagues in the patent research world to comment on issues like the impact of the lack of transparency on patent assignees and the real person of interest in patent litigation.
Mr. Vishnubhakat, another Expert Advisor at USPTO, works in the Office of the Chief Economist. He works for Mr. Graham. According to public, "Saurabh Vishnubhakat advises the USPTO's Chief Economist and senior management on a range of issues including genetic patenting, IP assignment, international trademark examination, and technology standards. ...As part of the USPTO's implementation team for the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act, Saurabh helps administer a number of regulatory reforms, studies, and reports to Congress."
Mr. Vishnubhakat was an active participant in USPTO's efforts to deal with the problems associated with hiding the real interests in patents and perhaps more importantly, patent litigation and the Roundtable on Proposed Requirements for Real-Party-in-Interest Information Throughout Application Pendency and Patent Term published in the Federal Register. USPTO sought comments on means for collecting and dissemination information about who the real owner of the patent applications and patents and how the USPTO what USPTO can do to collect more timely and accurate patent assignment information during patent prosecution and during it's term. He was the conduit through which organizations submitted comments to USPTO. (Here's an example.)
So what's going on here? Mr. Graham and Mr. Vishnubhakat both work for USPTO. Neither is simply an Expert Advisor doing some work at USPTO as a break from academia. Both are active participants in research and analysis and are directly involved in policy strategy and formulation and the implementation of the new Leahy-Smith America Invents Act. Why didn't the bios on the article reflect that? Why did the editor of the Journal of Economic Perspectives not require a more accurate bio?
So the guys at USPTO who are working on seeking input on changing the rules of the game with respect to hiding the real-person-in-interest in patents are obfuscating their relationship with USPTO in academic articles.
Obfuscation must be contagious in the patentsphere. A little transparency might be in order here.
(Oh - and the whole cotton gin, sewing machine, laser discussion gets a little hackneyed when you consider that the level of complexity in the patent system hadn't reached today's breathtaking complexity when these inventors were duking it out. Just look at the size of the footnote needed to define the universe of software patents.)
Update - 4:47pm
This afternoon we reached out to the Editor of the Journal of Economic Perspectives (JEP) on their editorial policy with respect to the biographical information of their contributors.
Ms. Ann Norman Assistant Editor, JEP relayed the following, "Stuart Graham was Chief Economist at USPTO and now is an Expert Advisor. That status changed only at the last minute, apparently, at the last stages of preparing to send this paper for printing…
"So the authors did disclose their potential conflicts of interest to us, and it was/is an editorial decision as to whether these conflicts were significant enough to post online. We can, in-fact still post the full disclosure statements with the paper, though of course it is too late to mention in the paper itself that the online disclosure statement exists."
Ms. Norman graciously provided the full disclosures statements for both each author which confirm the status change.
We appreciate the timely response to our inquiry. We still believe it is important to the readers of articles about patents that the affiliations of the authors are known. We believe information transparency is an important element in fixing the perception that the patent system is broken. We don't believe it's broke we believe that the system needs more transparency.
According to the abstract, "Principally, the article highlights how the US Patent Office acts responsibly when it engages constructively with principled criticisms and calls for reform as it has during the passage and now implementation of the landmark Leahy-Smith America Invents Act of 2011."
Fundamentally this is an articles designed to show that software patents aren't handled any differently at USPTO than other patents. The authors select a group of patent classifications to define software patents and use the behavior of the patents in comparison with other non-software patents to illustrate that the USPTO outcomes are similar.
(We could make the argument that if we shifted the Classes included in the paper here and there, that the outcome might be different. It is also curious that after the big build up to the new Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC) system by USPTO, that the authors didn't elect to use the new classifications in their article. But we digress.)
But there is something very curious here. Who are the authors?
The articles bibliographic information about the authors says,
"Stuart J. H. Graham is an Expert Advisor to the US Patent and Trademark Office. He is an Assistant Professor, Scheller College of Busines, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia and is an attorney licensed in the State of New York. Saurabh Vishnubhakat is an Expert Advisor at the US Patent and Trademark Office. He is an Adjunct Professor at the Norther Virginia Community College, Alexandria, Virginia and is licensed in the State of Illinois."
Expert Advisors to the USPTO and academics. Well, not quite.
Stuart Graham is the Chief Economist at USPTO. Or as noted on the USPTO website, "The USPTO established the Office of the Chief Economist (OCE) in March 2010, with the appointment of Dr. Stuart Graham as its first Chief Economist. The Chief Economist is responsible for advising the Under Secretary and the Administrator for External Affairs on the economic implications of policies and programs affecting the United States intellectual property system. The Chief Economist initiates and oversees groundbreaking economic analysis in the field on the topics of intellectual property protection and enforcement, with the object of fulfilling the USPTO’s statutory obligation to provide the President (through the Secretary of Commerce) and the Administration with advice on intellectual property policy." Dr. Graham has a considerable research agenda at USPTO and is the public fact of many of the Office's outreach efforts including encouraging colleagues in the patent research world to comment on issues like the impact of the lack of transparency on patent assignees and the real person of interest in patent litigation.
Mr. Vishnubhakat, another Expert Advisor at USPTO, works in the Office of the Chief Economist. He works for Mr. Graham. According to public, "Saurabh Vishnubhakat advises the USPTO's Chief Economist and senior management on a range of issues including genetic patenting, IP assignment, international trademark examination, and technology standards. ...As part of the USPTO's implementation team for the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act, Saurabh helps administer a number of regulatory reforms, studies, and reports to Congress."
Mr. Vishnubhakat was an active participant in USPTO's efforts to deal with the problems associated with hiding the real interests in patents and perhaps more importantly, patent litigation and the Roundtable on Proposed Requirements for Real-Party-in-Interest Information Throughout Application Pendency and Patent Term published in the Federal Register. USPTO sought comments on means for collecting and dissemination information about who the real owner of the patent applications and patents and how the USPTO what USPTO can do to collect more timely and accurate patent assignment information during patent prosecution and during it's term. He was the conduit through which organizations submitted comments to USPTO. (Here's an example.)
So what's going on here? Mr. Graham and Mr. Vishnubhakat both work for USPTO. Neither is simply an Expert Advisor doing some work at USPTO as a break from academia. Both are active participants in research and analysis and are directly involved in policy strategy and formulation and the implementation of the new Leahy-Smith America Invents Act. Why didn't the bios on the article reflect that? Why did the editor of the Journal of Economic Perspectives not require a more accurate bio?
So the guys at USPTO who are working on seeking input on changing the rules of the game with respect to hiding the real-person-in-interest in patents are obfuscating their relationship with USPTO in academic articles.
Obfuscation must be contagious in the patentsphere. A little transparency might be in order here.
(Oh - and the whole cotton gin, sewing machine, laser discussion gets a little hackneyed when you consider that the level of complexity in the patent system hadn't reached today's breathtaking complexity when these inventors were duking it out. Just look at the size of the footnote needed to define the universe of software patents.)
Update - 4:47pm
This afternoon we reached out to the Editor of the Journal of Economic Perspectives (JEP) on their editorial policy with respect to the biographical information of their contributors.
Ms. Ann Norman Assistant Editor, JEP relayed the following, "Stuart Graham was Chief Economist at USPTO and now is an Expert Advisor. That status changed only at the last minute, apparently, at the last stages of preparing to send this paper for printing…
"So the authors did disclose their potential conflicts of interest to us, and it was/is an editorial decision as to whether these conflicts were significant enough to post online. We can, in-fact still post the full disclosure statements with the paper, though of course it is too late to mention in the paper itself that the online disclosure statement exists."
Ms. Norman graciously provided the full disclosures statements for both each author which confirm the status change.
We appreciate the timely response to our inquiry. We still believe it is important to the readers of articles about patents that the affiliations of the authors are known. We believe information transparency is an important element in fixing the perception that the patent system is broken. We don't believe it's broke we believe that the system needs more transparency.
Labels:
Journal of Economic Perspectives,
Saurabh Vishnubhakat,
software patents,
Stuart Graham,
USPTO
Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Deja Vu - Blimps, Aerostats and Airships
Lighter-than-air (LTA) aircraft are currently in the news with the successful “first-float” maneuver completed for the prototype Aeroscraft designed by Worldwide Aeros CEO, Founder, and Chief Engineer Igor Pasternak. The Aeroscraft uses a pressurized helium system to achieve buoyancy. Its development has been supported by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), the US Defense Department Defiance’s Rapid Reaction Technology Office, and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). Pasternak received a US design patent, D663,255, “Rigid body airship,” in July 2012.
(On the accompanying patent drawing, 100 is the airship, which includes a shell (102), a strake (104), and a tail (106). A strake is an aerodynamic surface mounted on the fuselage of an aircraft to improve airflow and flight characteristics.)
Rather than relying on helium for buoyancy, the Boeing Company (NYSE: BA) envisioned a system in which both a lighter-than-air gas and heated air would be used in concert. Issued US Patent 8,033,497 in October 2011 for “Hybrid thermal airship,” inventors David Kwok and co-inventors designed,
"[a]n airship [that] comprises a shell, a gas storage system, an air storage system, a cargo storage system, a heating system, and a propulsion system. The shell encompasses a volume. The gas storage system is located within the volume, wherein the gas storage system is capable of storing a lighter than air gas. The air storage system is located within the volume, wherein the air storage system is capable of storing heated air. The heating system is capable of heating air. The propulsion system is capable of propelling the shell during flight."
The airship’s design would allow it to operate at an altitude of about 30,000 feet above sea level, and it was intended to provide cargo transportation. The inventors stated that “cargo is placed into the cargo storage system while a negative buoyancy is present [i.e., when the airship is on the ground]. After the cargo has been placed into the cargo storage system, the temperature of the stored air in the gas storage system is changed to create a variable buoyancy.
Further, “[i]t is also a general goal to reduce the drag force of airships so that less fuel is burned. Alternatively, it is desirable to reduce drag so that the airship may fly faster with the same fuel consumption.” The Boeing hybrid thermal airship can be considered clean tech within the Way Better Patents Transportation Index.
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) report, Future Aerostat and Airship Investment Decisions Drive Oversight and Coordination Needs, issued in October 2012 identified 15 key aerostat and airship efforts that were underway or had been initiated since 2007, and the Department of Defense (DOD) had or has primary responsibility for all of these efforts. Most of the aerostat and airship efforts have been fielded or completed, and are intended to provide intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) support. The estimated total funding of these efforts was almost $7 billion from fiscal years 2007 through 2012. Most of the total estimated airship investment from fiscal years 2007 to 2012—approximately $1.1 billion—consists of research, development, test, and evaluation (RDT&E) costs. A significant investment that should yield many new inventions.
(Airships, which use a lifting gas—most commonly helium, are manned or unmanned, self-propelled vehicles that have directional control. Aerostats are the airship's tethered siblings.)
News reports a little over a month before the patent issued said that Boeing was no longer working on the airship. The US Air Force and other have dramatically reduced spending on airship and aerostat development. Perhaps another company will purchase or license the Boeing patent, and this clean tech will be brought to market.
Blimps, aerostats, and airships are likely to make another appearance in the future not unlike the other clean technology like the windmill that have returned to the fore. In any event, innovative approaches to solving problems incorporating aspects of clean tech continue to be brought forth by the nation’s inventors.
Labels:
Aeroscraft,
aerostat,
aviation,
blimps,
Boeing,
hybrid thermal airship,
patentECO,
Worldwide Aeros
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







